The Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) has issued its first public report on how U.S. intelligence agencies buy commercially available information (CAI), the data that brokers and apps collect and sell. In a November 5 Lawfare analysis, Justin Sherman credits the report with adding new disclosure. He argues that it also leaves federal law enforcement as the conspicuous gap: no comparable framework or report exists for the FBI or the components of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
What the ODNI Report Disclosed
According to Sherman, ODNI published its 2026 Commercially Available Information Report in September 2026. It follows a declassified 2022 advisory-panel study, released in June 2023, and the May 2024 Intelligence Community Policy Framework for Commercially Available Information, which incoming ODNI leadership endorsed in spring 2025. The framework treats a subset of CAI as "sensitive." That subset is data with a substantial volume of personally identifiable information about U.S. persons, more than a de minimis volume of sensitive attributes such as religion or sexual orientation, or data that reveals a pattern of life.
Sherman summarizes the new figures as follows:
- Drawing on an earlier update to Congress, the report states that seven intelligence community elements accessed or purchased 23 sensitive datasets.
- Those datasets made up 3.8 percent of the community's 2025 spending on commercial data. The report gave neither their cost nor the total spend.
- Six of the 23 were described as "U.S." focused. All six supported a consent-based counterespionage program in which intelligence community personnel consent to access to their data for clearance vetting.
- Sensitive CAI is used mainly to identify and analyze foreign threats. It is also used for compliance, security and personnel functions.
- Each element's legal counsel and civil liberties and privacy officer is responsible for oversight.
- Controls include a risk analysis before acquisition. They may also include policies requiring analysts to mask or label U.S.-person data.
The Law Enforcement Gap
The core of Sherman's argument concerns agencies with domestic arrest powers. He notes that FBI Director Kash Patel told the Senate Intelligence Committee in March 2026 that the bureau buys CAI "consistent with the Constitution" and the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. By Sherman's account, it was the FBI's first public statement on the subject since then-Director Christopher Wray's March 2023 testimony. Sherman also recounts a September 2023 DHS inspector general report. It found that Customs and Border Protection, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the Secret Service bought commercial telemetry data, including historical phone location data, without following department privacy policies. According to the report, ICE had no data-specific procedures. Sherman adds that a January ICE request for information suggests such buying may continue.
Writing in Lawfare's Seriously Risky Business newsletter after the March hearing, Tom Uren reported that committee chair Sen. Tom Cotton defended the purchases. Uren argued that the FBI's domestic and coercive powers call for a different balance than foreign intelligence work does. He proposed the same warrant requirement that applies to cell phone location data.
The Warrant Workaround Debate
The policy dispute turns on whether purchase sidesteps the Fourth Amendment. In a July 2026 Just Security article, Faiza Patel wrote that agencies take the position that the warrant requirement in Carpenter v. United States covers records the government compels from a company. In their view it does not cover data bought on the open market. She also criticized the 2024 CAI framework. In her account, it does not name even obvious sensitive categories, such as location data, and it lets each agency decide what counts as a "substantial" volume or a pattern of life. Sherman frames warrantless bulk purchases as at odds with Fourth Amendment principles. He also notes the unresolved question of whether such purchases amount to buying a way around the amendment.
Legislative Proposals
As Patel described the record in July, the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act passed the House in 2024, but the Senate did not take it up. The bipartisan Government Surveillance Reform Act remained pending. Uren wrote that the latter would, among other things, require a warrant before the government buys sensitive data about Americans. Sherman's November piece does not track any bill's progress. Instead, he urges congressional oversight committees to question the Justice Department (including the FBI and the Drug Enforcement Administration) and DHS (including CBP and ICE) on the record about their purchases. His proposed questions cover:
- what types of data they buy and how much they spend;
- their purposes, and any sharing or fusion with other data;
- how much of the data is sensitive;
- privacy impact assessments and audit controls;
- misconduct investigations;
- their plans for the next 12 months.
He sees bipartisan interest as an opening for the next Congress.
Sources
- Where Is Federal Law Enforcement's Data-Buying Transparency? — lawfaremedia.org/article/where-is-federal-law-enforcement-s-data-buying-transparency
- FBI Says Why Get a Warrant When You Have Kash — lawfaremedia.org/article/fbi-says-why-get-a-warrant-when-you-have-kash
- AI and the Commercial Data Loophole — justsecurity.org/148430/ai-surveillance-commercial-data-loophole/