Online edition

A federal district court in Oklahoma has held that a deputy's warrantless query of a multistate license plate reader database violated the Fourth Amendment. In a Nov. 10 Lawfare analysis, Matthew Tokson of the University of Utah argues that the ruling echoes the Supreme Court's June 2026 decision in Chatrie v. United States and that Chatrie's reasoning places dense automated license plate reader (ALPR) networks, including those built on Flock Safety cameras, on uncertain constitutional ground. The doctrinal path from Carpenter through Chatrie to roadside cameras is now visible, but much of it remains unsettled.

What Chatrie Held

Chatrie arose from a 2019 credit union robbery in Virginia. As described by Michael Dreeben in Just Security and Christy Lopez in Lawfare, investigators obtained a three-step geofence warrant directing Google to identify devices within 150 meters of the scene during a one-hour window, then to expand location data for a subset of those devices, and finally to unmask a small number of users. Lopez reports that the process surfaced 19 accounts, three of which were identified, one belonging to Okello Chatrie.

Writing for the Court, Justice Elena Kagan held that acquiring location history from Google was a Fourth Amendment search. The opinion applied the expectation-of-privacy framework of Katz and treated Google location history as sharing the essential features of the cell-site records at issue in Carpenter v. United States (2018). According to Dreeben, the Chief Justice and Justices Sotomayor, Jackson and Kavanaugh joined the opinion; Justice Gorsuch concurred on a property-based theory; and Justice Alito, joined by Justice Thomas and in part by Justice Barrett, dissented, warning of an "upheaval" in Fourth Amendment law.

Two moves in the majority opinion matter most for later cases. First, the Court discarded the durational limit that Carpenter had left open, reasoning that even brief location records can expose visits to sensitive places and that a time-based threshold would invite unworkable line-drawing. Second, it declined to treat a user's opt-in to Google's location service as a voluntary disclosure that forfeits protection, and questioned how voluntary such opt-ins are in practice. Lopez notes that Justice Gorsuch described the result as a possible "quiet burial" of the third-party doctrine for smartphone data.

The Court did not decide whether the warrant itself was valid. It remanded questions of particularity and probable cause to the Fourth Circuit, leaving undisturbed, in Dreeben's reading, the Fifth Circuit's position that geofence warrants are categorically unconstitutional general warrants. Justices Jackson and Sotomayor would have held the warrant's expansion steps unconstitutional. Both commentators also observe that the good-faith exception may keep Chatrie's conviction intact, as it did for Timothy Carpenter.

From Phones to Plates

Before Chatrie, ALPR challenges generally failed. Tokson identifies the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's 2020 decision in Commonwealth v. McCarthy, which upheld cameras at a handful of points on major roads because they captured too little to reveal a person's private life, and notes that several federal courts reached similar results.

Two decisions now cut the other way. In 2024, a Virginia state court in Commonwealth v. Bell held that Norfolk's network of 172 Flock cameras functioned like a tracking device and that its use was a search. Then, on Oct. 1, U.S. District Judge Sara Hill ruled in United States v. Kyle that a Tulsa deputy sheriff's query of a California plate, which returned more than 50 sightings across several states over 30 days, violated the Fourth Amendment. Tokson reports that the court, following the approach of Kyllo and Carpenter, took account of more sophisticated systems already in use or in development, and that its concern about revealing trips paralleled the sensitive-location reasoning in Chatrie. He also notes that the record left the number of cameras involved unclear, a disclosure gap he describes as common in ALPR litigation.

Tokson distills from Chatrie three considerations: whether the data can reveal personal details, whether the technique has the potential for extensive surveillance, and whether the person disclosed the information so broadly as to waive protection. He regards the second and third as relatively clear for ALPRs, since Flock retention can run as long as agencies choose and driving is an ordinary, largely unavoidable activity. The contested question is the first: whether a given network is dense enough to reveal private life.

What Remains Open

Several questions are unresolved. Tokson himself states that ALPR status "remains ambiguous" after Chatrie and that lower courts may split. Outcomes may turn on camera density, retention periods and data-sharing arrangements, facts that police often do not fully disclose. Courts must also decide whether to assess a system as actually used in a case or, as the Kyle court did, in light of foreseeable capabilities. Kyle is a single district court ruling, and Bell is a Virginia state court decision; neither binds courts elsewhere.

The remedy question is equally open. Lopez cautions that the contours of the right will be set largely in suppression hearings, where exceptions to the exclusionary rule and judicial deference to law enforcement may narrow protection over time. A separate Lawfare essay published Oct. 6 by Matthew Cavedon and Laura Bondank-Harmon of the Cato Institute observes that the Supreme Court has not addressed whether pulling data from tens of thousands of Flock cameras is a search, and cites reporting that Flock has built AI tools able to track vehicles by movement patterns and link plates to names and addresses. Such capabilities bear directly on the "reveals private life" inquiry.

Government purchases of commercial location data present a related gap that Chatrie does not resolve, as both Dreeben and Lopez note; Lopez points to pending Senate legislation addressing it.

Implications for Law Enforcement and Vendors

For agencies, one cautious reading of Kyle is to treat historical, multiday ALPR queries, particularly those that reach across shared regional or national networks, as requiring a warrant absent an emergency, and to document the scope of the system queried. Cavedon and Bondank-Harmon highlight model legislation from the Institute for Justice that would require warrants for nonemergency review of historical location data, limit transfers to third parties, and mandate access documentation and officer training.

For vendors, system design is now part of the constitutional analysis. Retention defaults, which Tokson reports range from seven to 30 days for Flock customers, network density, cross-jurisdiction sharing and AI-driven correlation features all bear on whether a query reveals the details of a person's life. Cavedon and Bondank-Harmon report that Illinois regulators found Flock had violated state limits on the use of ALPR data for immigration enforcement, a reminder that statutory compliance exposure runs alongside the constitutional questions. Tokson reports that more than 80 cities have canceled or declined to renew ALPR contracts amid the controversy.

Chatrie did not decide the ALPR question, but its rejection of short-duration and opt-in exceptions gives lower courts a framework that, in Tokson's view, points toward a warrant requirement for pervasive ALPR systems; Kyle, which relied on Kyllo and Carpenter, reasoned along parallel lines. Appellate review will determine whether that view holds.

Sources

How to cite

JLCW Research Desk, After Chatrie, Courts Begin Testing Warrantless License Plate Reader Searches, J.L. & Cyber Warfare (2026), https://www.jlcw.org/articles/after-chatrie-courts-test-warrantless-license-plate-reader-searches.

Export BibTeXRIS